Why is Amazon restricting the voluntary return guarantee?

What does the limitation of the voluntary return guarantee mean for Amazon sellers?

Amazon limits the voluntary return guarantee to reduce systematic misuse and inefficient return processes.
The aim is to make returns more transparent and to reduce the return rate.

synopsis

Amazon specifically adjusts the conditions for voluntary returns when retailers stand out due to too high return rates, late refunds or poor customer service. The return guarantee remains a voluntary additional offer — but only if certain service figures and guidelines are consistently met.

Amazon tightens return policies — these are the reasons

By restricting the voluntary return guarantee, Amazon is responding to various factors that customer satisfaction and the Complaint process adversely affect. This applies in particular to:

• Disproportionate number of returns per item category (e.g. for fashion, electronics, or beauty products)
• Refund processing times that jeopardize customer loyalty
• Complaints about incomplete or late returns

The aim is to returns management to professionalize and persuade retailers to comply with defined quality indicators. In doing so, Amazon also wants to ensure that returns are handled fairly, transparently and comprehensibly for customers.

Amazon checks these KPIs particularly critically when returning goods

Amazon uses Seller Central to measure various Performance metrics (Key Performance Indicators) to decide on restrictions on return rights.

Relevant tracking metrics:

• Return rate per category (e.g. above 10% as a threshold)
• Refund processing time (should be less than 48 hours)
• Response time to return requests (max. 24 hours recommended)
• Original order shipping time (fast shipping reduces risk of returns)
• Ratio between accepted and rejected returns

Important: Merchants who repeatedly stand out due to poor values risk the automatic deactivation of voluntary return options — with no option to reactivate without internal verification.

Practical example: Restriction despite good intentions

A home appliance retailer offers voluntary returns of up to 60 days. Although all returns are accepted fairly, the return rate rises to over 20%, especially for accessories with a lower value of goods. Amazon will contact Seller Central and warn of a policy violation.
After 30 days without a noticeable reduction in the quota, the voluntary return guarantee is automatically deactivated — with immediate effect.

This example shows: Even benevolent service can lead to Amazon measures through incorrect processes. Efficient return processes and targeted analysis of return reasons are therefore crucial.

For beginners: What is the voluntary return guarantee on Amazon?

Die voluntary return guarantee is a customer-friendly addition that exceeds the legally required Right of Withdrawal goes out. Retailers can thus extend return periods, enable easy returns or make customer-friendly goodwill arrangements.
Many customers expect this option on Amazon — but is subject to compliance with clear Amazon guidelines and service standards. Retailers who do not comply with the return requirements can be permanently excluded from this additional offer.

Common misconceptions when it comes to restricting returns

“Amazon penalizes heavy returns. ”
Wrong. Amazon does not rate the absolute number, but analyses Abnormalities, patterns, and repetitions — e.g. a disproportionate return rate compared to the product category.

“I was not informed. ”
Wrong. Amazon usually instructs retailers in writing or via Seller Central for violations of the rules — often with a 30-day period for correction.

“The return guarantee is mandatory. ”
No She is volunteered, but can be used to increase conversion rate, Visibility in search results and customer loyalty contribute.

What retailers can do now

In order to maintain the voluntary return guarantee, retailers should implement the following measures:

• Regular Monitoring the return rate per product group
• Schnelle Processing refunds (max. 48 hours)
• Setting up an automated returns management
• Optimizing the product descriptionsto avoid unnecessary returns
• Customer service team training on return processes

In the long term, this investment in return quality pays off — because it not only strengthens customer trust, but also their own brand perception on Amazon.

More information & help

Reading tip:
👉 Amazon limits voluntary return guarantee — 7 facts

Do you need help with return processes or seller compliance?
➡ Get in touch now — our Amazon consulting team is here to help

Conclusion

The voluntary return guarantee remains an important tool for customer loyalty — but only if it is implemented efficiently. Who, as a retailer, is Has service KPIs under control, makes return processes comprehensible and detects misuse at an early stage, will sell more successfully in the long term — with or without Amazon's voluntary return guarantee.

Other questions that users frequently ask:

How can I improve my return rate on Amazon?

Reduce unnecessary returns with accurate product descriptions, fast delivery and good customer service.
Professional returns management lowers the rate in the long term and protects your voluntary return guarantee.

What are the return policies of FBM retailers?

FBM sellers must comply with Amazon's minimum requirements, but may set their own return policy.
However, these must be no worse than Amazon standards when voluntary returns are offered.

What happens if Amazon deactivates my return guarantee?

The visibility of the offer may fall and the conversion rate may suffer.
In addition, there is no important competitive advantage compared to other providers with a return guarantee.

‍